Vintage, Hand-Tinted Look

This is the Day Three Assignment (homework caught up!)
I'm not sure if I like it. Maybe the wrong picture?
Maybe operator-error? The goal is for a soft antique feel.

The original unedited photo

The vintage photo (reduced the color saturation and added a pale pink tint to cheeks and lips).

I remember pictures of my mother with VERY pink cheeks and lips.
Long eyelashes hand-drawn, too. She looked beautiful.

You know, Lauren's vintage picture is starting to grow on me.